Gina Greco

Marketing Concepts: 3 telltale signs your homepage is not customer-focused

August 9th, 2013

As a research manager, when I look at a homepage, I always ask myself two questions …

  • Who are the customers?
  • Was the homepage designed with those customers in mind?

I often find a homepage design makes perfect sense to the company’s executives, but not to the most important audience, the customers.

As homepages increasingly become the center of a company’s marketing and sales universe, making sure your focus is on the customer is more important than ever.

In today’s MarketingSherpa Blog post, I wanted to share three common telltale signs your homepage is driven by company-centric marketing.

I’m sure this post is likely to raise a few eyebrows, but my goal here is to help you raise revenue by helping you see your marketing efforts through the eyes of your potential customers.


Sign #1. Our homepage is a collage of department products instead of popular products

I generally tend to hope the most popular products and services offered on a homepage within direct eye-path, which is also prime real estate on a homepage, are what customers came to your homepage to find, versus products and services the company wants to sell.

However, it is not always that simple when you are in a large company with various departments with different sales goals all competing for that prime real estate on the homepage.

The big issue with this is when departments become only focused on the product or service, and marketers lose sight of what the customers want.

If a product or service that is not the primary driver of your sales traffic is overtaken on the homepage by a minimal interest product or service, should it really be placed within the customer’s direct eye-path?

The obvious answer is no, and I understand it is more complicated than that.

I also understand the chances of success for a business model that tries to force the sale of products or services to people who don’t need or want them are also slim in the long run.

So, if you find yourself in this position, I encourage you to take a step back and develop a strategy to work collaboratively with other departments to build a homepage that improves the overall customer experience.


Sign #2. Our value copy talks “at” our customers instead of “to” our customers

Have you ever read about a new product and still had to ask yourself, “What is this thing and what will it do for me?”

Unfortunately, this happens frequently.

Sometimes, we try to impress our customers with creative copy, hoping to sound professional and intelligent. This is great as long as it makes sense to the customer.

Remember, you understand your products/services inside and out and your potential customers are more than likely just learning about it for the first time.

The value copy from a customer’s perspective should answer one essential question – what is in it for me?


For example, I did a quick search online about cloud services, which is a complex product, and the first homepage I found left me even more confused.

Some of the cloud’s value copy explained this company’s service features“Open architecture based on OpenStack technology with no vendor lock-in.”

That may be an awesome feature, but I have no idea what it means.

Some of this company’s customers may understand this terminology, but the majority of customers are likely left just as confused as I am. Failing to provide clear and digestible information for customers could induce anxiety, increase frustration and ultimately leave visitors with no choice but to exit your page.

So, when I looked at the next cloud service homepage in my search, here’s what I found …


This homepage makes no assumptions about my level of IT sophistication.

It offers a short video and even lays out copy explaining what cloud service is and how it can help me.

And, there’s more …


Further down the page I found links to the options available that offer additional short videos combined with value copy explaining what cloud computing is and how the option can help me.

Now don’t get me wrong, there’s plenty to optimize on this homepage as well.

The overall point here is to understand that I left the first homepage confused about how a solution could help me and I left this one with a clear understanding of what cloud service is and how it could help me.


Sign #3. Our homepage is a web of clutter and confusion

The purpose of a homepage is usually to help guide the customer to where they need to go on the site.

But, if a homepage is littered with text, copy, images links and form fields all competing for attention, it’s likely that customer disorientation resulting from hidden friction is impacting your conversion.

One interesting insight on clutter from Tony Doty, Associate Director of Optimization, MECLABS, is that “a cluttered homepage is a symptom of an illness.”

The illness Tony is talking about is having fragmented business objectives, each department needing placement on the homepage to hit their numbers, but without a clear understanding of customer needs. It’s a sign of a business acting as many smaller silos and not as one well-coordinated group.

So, to help you sort through the clutter, remember what Flint McGlaughlin, Managing Director, MECLABS, teaches: the homepage should answer three main questions for customers almost instantly:

  • Where am I?
  • What can I do here?
  • Why should I do it with you?

A homepage should have a distinct headline that both entices and informs. (Where am I?)

The homepage should also help the visitor navigate to the part of the site that meets their needs. (What can I do here?)

Homepage copy should promote your main objectives with brief bullets that add value to your products or services, leaving  the major details for a separate landing page within the site dedicated to presenting the heart of your offer – the value proposition. (Why should I do it with you?)

In summary, homepages are one of the most important pages on a website. It welcomes a new visitor and is influential in converting those visitors into customers.

While there are no easy solutions, implementing a testing and optimization process that puts customers at the forefront of a homepage is certainly a step in the right direction.


Related Resources:

Testing: 3 common barriers to test planning

Online Marketing: 3 website optimization insights I learned from baking

Marketing Process: Managing your business leader’s testing expectations

Gina Greco

About Gina Greco

Gina Greco, Senior Research Manager, MECLABS As a research manager, Gina works with her Partners in a multitude of different areas including landing pages, banner ads, email templates and shopping cart experiences to help optimize and test for increased results. She began her career with MECLABS in 2011 and has helped multiple Partners with test strategies and optimization efforts. Before MECLABS, Gina worked as a manager for Citibank and graduated with a degree from the University of North Florida, where she majored in marketing. In her spare time she enjoys walking her dog, Cannoli, on the beach and spending time with friends and family.

Categories: Online Marketing Tags: , , , , ,

  1. August 9th, 2013 at 10:06 | #1

    All great points, Gina! I’ve also found that it’s extremely helpful to sort your clients into groups, into client personas. Then the content on your site can be reworked to make sure that it addresses all of the different personas and their needs.

  2. August 11th, 2013 at 01:13 | #2

    I really agree with your points, especially having clutter on the homepage. I should redo mine. Thanks.

  3. August 12th, 2013 at 08:12 | #3

    Great article – I think we are often guilty of pushing the products we want to sell rather than offering the products consumers want to buy.

  4. August 12th, 2013 at 10:49 | #4

    Good timely advice indeed. As regards home pages ‘less’ is often the best.
    We need to re-work ours, having read your advice…..there is always a conflict between useful info , ease of use and Search engine optimization. Getting them all right is a tricky task.

  5. March 14th, 2016 at 18:56 | #5

    I am guilty… my homepage is way too distracting. Sometimes we just get so busy looking after client’s we neglect the very page that our client’s first saw us on. Thanks for the ‘wake up call’ Gina 🙂

We no longer accept comments on the MarketingSherpa blog, but we'd love to hear what you've learned about customer-first marketing. Send us a Letter to the Editor to share your story.